{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "status": "SOURCE_DISAGREEMENT_NOT_GAME_VERIFIED",
  "checkedDate": "2026-10-31",
  "communityDefinition": "Existing bundled wiki/community +0 facts; source page is not guaranteed to describe Regulation 1.17.3",
  "pinnedDefinition": "Pinned public Regulation v1.17 parameter-derived +0 facts after applying exact reinforcement level-0 attack multiplier; neither current Regulation 1.17.3 nor independently inspected game menu",
  "pinnedSourceUrl": "https://github.com/ThomasJClark/elden-ring-weapon-calculator/blob/3539d87e446f3b9d5b94157f8a2023e28ffea7d2/public/regulation-vanilla-v1.17.js",
  "officialPatchUrl": "https://en.bandainamcoent.eu/elden-ring/news/elden-ring-patch-notes-version-1172",
  "requiredGameVersion": {
    "app": "1.17.2",
    "regulation": "1.17.3"
  },
  "verification": {
    "acceptedCurrentGameScreenshots": 0,
    "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
    "gameClientVerified": false,
    "publicationApproved": false
  },
  "reviewProcess": [
    "Open installed title screen and capture App and Regulation versions in the same documented session.",
    "Open the exact named weapon at reinforcement +0, uninfused/default affinity; capture the individual equipment weapon-details base attack or attribute requirements, not character Status AR.",
    "For a split-attack weapon record all five displayed base attack components. For the requirement conflict record STR/DEX/INT/FAI/ARC, not effective two-hand STR.",
    "Retain screenshots locally with platform, date, weapon name, +level, affinity and local SHA-256. Do not commit copyrighted screenshots or personally identifying game/account details.",
    "Independent reviewer manually inspects original image evidence and version/conditions before accepting a correction or clearing any conflict flag."
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-032",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        75,
        0,
        32,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        75,
        0,
        22,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Fire_Knight%27s_Shortsword",
      "other": "https://eldenring.fandom.com/wiki/Fire_Knight%27s_Shortsword",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "withinPageZeroContradiction": {
        "sourceUrl": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Fire_Knight%27s_Shortsword",
        "samePageStats": [
          75,
          0,
          32,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "samePageStandardZero": [
          72,
          0,
          22,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "pinnedV117": [
          75,
          0,
          22,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "category": "unreconciled-published-source-internal-base-attack-contradiction",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "note": "Wiki.gg's basic Stats section gives Physical 75 / Fire 32; its Standard +0 upgrading table gives Physical 72 / Fire 22. Pinned v1.17 says Physical 75 / Fire 22. Do not auto-select or splice fields into a purported verified vector."
      },
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/fire-knight-s-shortsword",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          75,
          0,
          22,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-041",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        129,
        83,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        127,
        82,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Greatsword_of_Radahn_%28Light%29",
      "other": "https://wiki.eso-ui.com/index.php/Elden_Ring%3AGreatsword_of_Radahn_%28Light%29",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/greatsword-of-radahn--light-",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          127,
          82,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-042",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        129,
        83,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        127,
        82,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Greatsword_of_Radahn_%28Lord%29",
      "other": "https://wiki.eso-ui.com/index.php/Elden_Ring%3AGreatsword_of_Radahn_%28Lord%29",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/greatsword-of-radahn--lord-",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          127,
          82,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-051",
      "field": "requirements",
      "community": [
        8,
        8,
        13,
        13,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        8,
        8,
        13,
        20,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Madding_Hand",
      "other": "https://eldenring.fandom.com/wiki/Madding_Hand_%28weapon%29",
      "priority": 1,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "currentPatchCorroboration": {
        "sourceUrl": "https://almanauts.com/eldenring/tiers/weapons-fist/",
        "patchChangeUrl": "https://almanauts.com/eldenring/patches/1-17-3/",
        "sourceClass": "independent-version-labelled-secondary-game-parameter-reference",
        "observedValues": [
          8,
          8,
          13,
          20,
          0
        ],
        "regulation": "1.17.3",
        "gameBuild": "25827938",
        "agreesWith": "pinned-v117",
        "notVerifiedByGameClient": true,
        "note": "This supports the pinned source's FAI 20 against unversioned wiki FAI 13; no independently reviewed +0 game menu screenshot exists."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-064",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        117,
        0,
        35,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        122,
        0,
        36,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Queelign%27s_Greatsword",
      "other": "https://wiki.eso-ui.com/index.php/Elden_Ring%3AQueelign%27s_Greatsword",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/queelign-s-greatsword",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          122,
          0,
          36,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-071",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        133,
        0,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        131,
        0,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Axe",
      "other": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/smithscript-axe",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/smithscript-axe",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          131,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sote-reference-058",
      "field": "baseAttack",
      "community": [
        67,
        0,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "pinned": [
        62,
        0,
        0,
        0,
        0
      ],
      "wiki": "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Smithscript_Dagger",
      "other": "https://wiki.eso-ui.com/index.php/Elden_Ring%3ASmithscript_Dagger",
      "priority": 2,
      "reviewStatus": "UNREVIEWED",
      "gameClientVerified": false,
      "screenshotCount": 0,
      "sourceClass": "community-vs-pinned-regulation",
      "needs": "Independent game client 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 +0 equipment-menu screenshot",
      "doNotAutoCorrect": true,
      "thirdPartyBasePlusZero": {
        "sourceName": "tarnished.app",
        "sourceUrl": "https://tarnished.app/weapons/smithscript-dagger",
        "fieldMeaning": "unupgraded-standard-base-attack-components",
        "observedComponents": [
          62,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "comparedTo": "pinned-public-Regulation-1.17",
        "agreement": "matches-pinned-vector",
        "referenceVersion": "unpublished-on-this-per-weapon-page",
        "independenceFromPinnedSource": "not-demonstrated",
        "conclusion": "provisional-corroborated-public-reference-only",
        "gameClientVerified": false,
        "publicationApproved": false,
        "note": "The public page's Base row matches the pinned Regulation 1.17 vector. This is an additional published cross-check, not proven independently extracted nor certified as App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3 game-client evidence."
      }
    }
  ],
  "currentPatchCrosscheckSummary": "Madding Hand requirement FAI 20 corroborated by an additional Regulation 1.17.3-labelled source; 6 +0 base attack discrepancies lack comparable current-patch +0 screenshot data. Original seven published source differences remain in the evidence ledger and all seven client captures remain unreviewed.",
  "thirdPartyBaseCrosscheck": {
    "schemaVersion": 1,
    "checkedDate": "2026-10-31",
    "scope": "six-uninfused-plus-zero-attack-disputes",
    "corroboratedPinnedSourceCount": 6,
    "totalOriginalAttackConflicts": 6,
    "candidateSource": "https://tarnished.app/weapons",
    "patchLabelOnWeaponPages": "not specified",
    "extractionLineageIndependentlyVerified": false,
    "independentGameClientScreenshots": 0,
    "gameClientVerified": false,
    "conclusion": "All six unversioned third-party +0 public Base rows agree with pinned Regulation 1.17, not with previous community +0 rows. Historical conflicts remain unresolved for game-client certification."
  },
  "trackedPatchContinuity": {
    "referenceScope": "third-party-version-difference-tracker-not-original-game-client",
    "trackerUrl": "https://almanauts.com/eldenring/patches/",
    "targetPatchUrl": "https://almanauts.com/eldenring/patches/1-17-3/",
    "fromV117ToV1171": "184-regulation-parameter-tables-hash-identical",
    "fromV1171ToV1173": "no-changes-to-tracked-headline-numeric-fields",
    "exceptionScope": "projectile-bullet-and-player-animation-tables-changed",
    "validatesSixWeaponAttackVectorsIndividually": false,
    "versionedPrimaryParameterDumpObtained": false,
    "gameClientVerified": false,
    "independentReviewerApproved": false,
    "note": "The tracker describes patch evolution and constrained tracked numeric fields; it cannot certify individual +0 weapon values or authenticate a separately supplied JSON."
  }
}